• Join or Renew
  • Login
  • Canadian Nurses Protective Society 1-800-267-3390
  • Switch LanguageFrançais
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
Canadian Nurses Protective Society
  • Switch Languagefr
  • Services
    • Services
    • Professional Liability Protection and Core Services
    • Supplementary Protection
    • Am I Eligible?
    • In need of urgent legal information?
  • Education & Resources
    • Education & Resources
    • Publications
    • Communities of Practice
    • Nursing Students
    • The NP Corner
    • Operating a business or independent practice?
    • Case Studies
  • News & Events
    • News & Events
    • Webinars
    • News
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • A Message from the CEO
    • Board of Directors
    • Who we are
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Careers
    • CNPS Member Organizations
Canadian Nurses Protective Society 1-800-267-3390
  • Need Urgent Advice?

InfoLAW: Examinations for Discovery

Canadian Nurses Protective Society > Legal Process > InfoLAW: Examinations for Discovery

Please note that the content on this page is currently under review. Please contact us at 1-800-267-3390 should you have any questions concerning this topic.

At some point in your nursing career you may be required to participate in an Examination for Discovery. The information covered in this infoLAW will assist you with your preparations for participating in this legal proceeding.

What is an Examination for Discovery?

After a civil lawsuit has been initiated and, normally, after the filing of a Statement of Defence, Examinations for Discovery are scheduled. Examinations for Discovery are a pre-trial proceeding which permits any party 1 to a civil lawsuit to obtain information about the case of any party who is adverse in interest to him. 2 They are usually conducted in a law firm’s conference room or a court reporter’s office, not in a court room, and are governed by the applicable provincial/territorial or federal Rules of Court in the jurisdiction where the litigation is commenced. Questions will be posed by opposing legal counsel. All of the questions and responses are recorded by a court reporter who transcribes the testimony into a written transcript.

There are primarily seven purposes for conducting a discovery. They include: understanding the nature of the other side’s case; obtaining a preview of the documentary evidence; gaining admissions for use at trial; committing an opposing witness to their testimony; fixing and narrowing the matters really in issue in the litigation; gaining a sense of the personalities of some of the witnesses who counsel will cross-examine at trial; 3 and gathering information to facilitate settlement. Additionally, the testimony from the discovery can be used by counsel at trial for a variety of purposes including contradicting the testimony of a trial witness.

Who may be examined and what is the scope of the Discovery?

The provisions in the Rules of Court stipulate who may be examined. In most jurisdictions, these rules permit a lawyer representing any party to the lawsuit to examine under oath any other party adverse in interest, any officer of a corporate party, and any employee or ex-employee of a corporate body who has knowledge of the matters in issue in the case. The scope of an Examination for Discovery is also governed by the provisions in the applicable Rules of Court. In Alberta, for example, the Rules of Court provide that “a person is required to answer only relevant and material questions.” 4 Relevant and material questions are questions which could reasonably be expected “to significantly help determine one or more of the issues raised in the pleadings, 5 or to ascertain evidence that could reasonably be expected to significantly help determine one or more of the issues raised in the pleadings.” 6

Do you need legal representation?

Yes. If you are to be examined at an Examination for Discovery, you should have legal representation. Your lawyer should ensure that you are fully prepared and understand the nature of the case before you are questioned. Many civil lawsuits have been lost at the discovery stage because of careless answers given by inadequately prepared or unrepresented witnesses.

How can you prepare?

You should do some independent preparation before meeting with your lawyer. This would include a review of all relevant documents such as: the patient record, any personal notes you prepared, statements you may have given, policies and procedures, letters and memos. At the pre-discovery meeting, your lawyer will probably review the documents, the pleadings, issues in the case and questions which opposing counsel may ask you. To help prepare you for your role as a witness, your lawyer may also assume the role of the opposing counsel and ask you detailed questions.

In addition to that preparation, there are a number of witness points you should keep in mind. When you respond to questions at the Examination for Discovery remember to: 7

    • Listen to the question and answer only that question. Do not volunteer information.
    • Wait until opposing counsel finishes the question before answering.
    • Take the time to think before answering.
    • Ask for clarification if you do not understand a question.
    • Admit that you do not know the answer to a question, if that is the case. You may provide the information at a later date by way of an undertaking.
    • Resist guessing when you are unsure e.g. measurements, amounts, times or distances.
    • Remain silent if your lawyer objects to a question. Respond when your lawyer directs you.
    • Be factual and concise. Do not ramble.
    • Avoid arguing with opposing counsel.
    • Answer “yes” or “no” if a question requires a “yes” or “no” response. The court reporter records responses verbatim and a “hum” or “uh ah” is an unclear response.

CNPS beneficiaries can contact CNPS at 1-800-267-3390 to speak with a member of CNPS legal counsel. All calls are confidential.


  1. A party to an action is a person who is named as a plaintiff or defendant. Refer to infoLAW Malpractice Lawsuits Vol. 7, No. 2, September 1998, online: www.cnps.ca.
  2. R. White, The Art of Discovery, (Aurora: Canada Law Book Inc., 1990) at 7.
  3. Ibid.
  4. Alberta Rules of Court, r. 200(1.2).
  5. Pleadings are “the formal allegations by the parties to a lawsuit which are found in their respective claims and defenses.” Black’s Law Dictionary, Sixth Edition, St. Paul, West Publishing, 1990, at 1152.
  6. Alberta Rules of Court, r. 186.1.
  7. Legal Education Society of Alberta, Alberta Bar Admission Course Materials, 1997/98, Civil Procedure, at X-5.

January 2004

 

THIS PUBLICATION IS FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY. NOTHING IN THIS PUBLICATION SHOULD BE CONSTRUED AS LEGAL ADVICE FROM ANY LAWYER, CONTRIBUTOR OR THE CNPS. READERS SHOULD CONSULT LEGAL COUNSEL FOR SPECIFIC ADVICE.

Request Materials

Should you require a CNPS branded printable version of this document for physical distribution purposes, please make a request.

Request Materials

Related Education Articles

  • InfoLAW: Expert Witness
  • The Nurse as an Expert Witness
  • InfoLAW: Malpractice Lawsuits
  • Ask a Lawyer: Providing an Expert Opinion
  • Ask a Lawyer: Engaging with non-compliant patients and discontinuing nursing services
Canadian Nurses Protective Society
  • Terms of Use
  • FAQs
  • Careers
  • Newsletter
  • Join or Renew
  • Login
© 2025 Canadian Nurses Protective Society
  • Contact Us
  • Accessibility Statement
  • CNPS Privacy Policy
  • Français

Before you start, please have on hand:

1. If you are renewing, the email address you used to register for CNPS PLP in 2022 (your 2022-2023 CNPS receipt would have been sent to that email address).

2. Your CRNA permit number (found in the top-right corner of College Connect when you are logged in).

3. If you are a member of the Alberta Association of Nurses (AAN), your AAN membership number. If you would like to receive the CNPS group rate, please visit www.albertanursing.ca and join/renew before beginning your CNPS registration.

By clicking on this link and completing my registration, I understand that if I decide to join the AAN later on, the CNPS is unable to refund my individual rate registration.

I accept and continue